If it ain't broke, don't fix it (we all know that saying) - but by all means, in a system that is quite obviously riddled with problems - give it an overhaul.
One Saskatchewan MP is currently piloting a bill to change the 136-year-old Indian Act. He compares it to the laws of South Africa's former apartheid regime.
"It's one of the most archaic things, the most systematic discriminations out there. It's the template for South African apartheid. That's what they used it for. I just want to get rid of it," says Desnethe-Missinippi-Churchill River MP Rob Clarke, whose bill was scheduled for debate this past Thursday in the House of Commons.
In a recent interview Clarke said he's been wanting to change the Indian Act since he was charged with enforcing it as an RCMP officer in the 1990s.
"I am hoping for a wholesome, open debate, and we'll go from there," he says.
As would be expected, Clarke's bill is being met with a bit of controversy and criticism. Some First Nations leaders are critical about a lack of consultation on a bill affecting their communities. Others wonder why changes are even needed.
One glance at the reserves in this province - and across Canada - makes it clear why change is needed if you ask me. We are contending with big problems in some areas - from hunger to homelessness to alcoholism and mistreatment. There is no question we have a system that's in need of improvement.
Reportedly Prime Minister Stephen Harper promised national chiefs earlier this year there would be no "unilateral" changes to the act and Clarke assures there will be plenty of opportunity for consultation and possible amendments if the bill survives to the committee stage. He also says he should know more about the level of support from Harper and the federal government as cabinet continues to meet.
While I'm not sure on the details Clarke is proposing, I am sure taxpayer dollars could be better spent and do more good than they are now. If Clarke is impetus needed for change then I say we at least hear him out. Some discussion is preferable to turning a blind eye to an age old way of doing things that does not serve anyone well.
